I agree I don't think there is any rationale on the way things are handled here.

Just had a thought - Here's another idea.

With Dolphin there is the possibility to create groups - just let everyone create their own group where they can set the rules and moderate it themselves. That way if you don't like the way some people communicate, or disagree with thier opinion - go create your own group.

The trolls can have their own group, so can the experienced users, noobs another group, there can see more be groups for controversial users and ones for women - no one need upset anyone else again.

:)